今天我就来反驳一下网上说,漠视小说只是对南方人恐怖北方人不恐怖的这个观点

3 活在梦里的猫猫 2小时前 87次点击


我们先从冰河世纪开始讲,先不用着急

冰河时期的温度以末次冰盛期(约2万年前)数据最为详实,这一时期全球平均温度约7.8℃,较现代全球平均温度低5-8℃,且降温呈现明显的区域差异。高纬度地区降温幅度最大,北极、格陵兰北部等地温度比现代低14-25℃,部分区域可达-30℃以下;中纬度地区降温5-8℃,温度维持在5-10℃左右;热带地区降温相对温和,约比现代低5.8℃,仍保持在20-25℃区间。这些温度数据基于冰芯分析、海洋沉积物研究等科学手段重建,是目前学界公认的真实古气候记录。

全球温度突然下降20℃属于极端假设推演,其后果将是全球性的毁灭性灾难。气候层面,全球会瞬间进入极端冰期,中低纬度平原将出现数米厚的持续降雪,河流、湖泊及近海快速冻结,海洋冰盖向赤道扩张,大气环流系统崩溃,风暴、寒潮频发。生态系统将全面崩溃,农作物几乎全部冻死导致全球粮食绝收,温带森林大片枯萎,热带植物近乎灭绝,仅少数耐寒植物能存活;草食动物因食物短缺和低温大量死亡,肉食动物随之陷入生存危机,冷血动物基本灭绝,食物链彻底断裂。人类社会将面临秩序崩塌,粮食储备仅够短期消耗,饥荒快速蔓延;电力、供暖、交通等基础设施因低温瘫痪,物资运输中断,医疗资源枯竭,冻伤、感染等疾病无法得到救治,全球人口将大幅锐减,人类文明面临严峻挑战。

针对“末日温度降20度对南方恐怖、北方人习以为常”的观点,实际情况并非如此。北方人习惯的是渐变式的冬季低温,且依赖完善的供暖系统、除雪设备和稳定的物资供应链,而末日20℃骤降是无任何缓冲的极端低温,北方冬季常规低温会在此基础上再降20℃,远超人体耐受极限。更关键的是,极端降温引发的基础设施瘫痪、供应链断裂、社会秩序崩塌是全球性的,北方的抗寒优势会随供暖中断、粮食耗尽而彻底消失,并非“抗冻就能解决”。这场灾难的核心是全球生态系统和人类生存支撑体系的全面崩溃,与地域无关,不存在北方人“习以为常”的可能,本质上是全人类共同面临的生存危机。


The temperature data of the Ice Age are most detailed for the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), approximately 20,000 years ago. During this period, the global average temperature was about 7.8°C, 5-8°C lower than the modern global average, with significant regional differences in cooling. High-latitude regions experienced the largest temperature drop: areas such as the Arctic and northern Greenland were 14-25°C colder than today, with some regions dropping below -30°C; mid-latitude regions cooled by 5-8°C, maintaining temperatures around 5-10°C; tropical regions saw a relatively mild cooling of about 5.8°C compared to modern times, remaining within the range of 20-25°C. These temperature data are reconstructed through scientific methods such as ice core analysis and marine sediment research, and are recognized by the academic community as authentic paleoclimate records.

A sudden global temperature drop of 20°C is an extreme hypothetical scenario, whose consequences would be a global catastrophic disaster. Climatically, the world would instantly enter an extreme ice age: mid-to-low latitude plains would see continuous snowfall several meters thick, rivers, lakes, and coastal waters would freeze rapidly, marine ice sheets would expand toward the equator, the atmospheric circulation system would collapse, and storms and cold waves would occur frequently. The ecosystem would completely collapse: almost all crops would freeze to death, leading to a global food failure; temperate forests would wither extensively, tropical plants would nearly become extinct, and only a few cold-tolerant plants could survive; herbivores would die in large numbers due to food shortages and low temperatures, followed by carnivores facing an existential crisis, cold-blooded animals would be almost extinct, and the food chain would be completely broken. Human society would face the collapse of order: food reserves would only be sufficient for short-term consumption, and famine would spread rapidly; infrastructure such as electricity, heating, and transportation would paralyzed by low temperatures, material transportation would be interrupted, medical resources would be exhausted, and diseases such as frostbite and infections could not be treated. The global population would drastically decrease, and human civilization would face severe challenges.

Regarding the view that "a 20°C temperature drop in the doomsday would be terrifying for southerners but commonplace for northerners," this is not the case. Northerners are accustomed to gradual winter low temperatures and rely on complete heating systems, snow removal equipment, and stable material supply chains. However, a sudden 20°C drop in the doomsday is an extreme low temperature without any buffer—regular winter low temperatures in the north would drop by another 20°C on this basis, far exceeding the human tolerance limit. More importantly, the collapse of infrastructure, supply chain disruptions, and social order breakdown caused by extreme cooling are global. The cold resistance advantages of the north would completely disappear with the interruption of heating and depletion of food, and it is not a problem that can be solved by "being cold-tolerant." The core of this disaster is the comprehensive collapse of the global ecosystem and human survival support system, which has nothing to do with geography. There is no possibility that northerners would find it "commonplace"; it is essentially an existential crisis for all humanity.

共 13 条评论
梦之星辰 2小时前
0 
翻译的还可以,翻译了最后一段 对于“世界末日气温下降20°C对南方人来说是可怕的,但对北方人来说却是司空见惯的”的观点,事实并非如此。北方人习惯了冬季逐渐低温,依赖完整的供暖系统、除雪设备和稳定的材料供应链。然而,末日突然下降20°C是没有任何缓冲的极端低温--北方常规冬季低温将在此基础上再下降20°C,远远超过人类的容忍极限。更重要的是,极端降温导致的基础设施崩溃、供应链中断、社会秩序崩溃是全球性的。北方的耐寒优势将随着供暖中断和食物枯竭而完全消失,这不是“耐寒”就能解决的问题。“这场灾难的核心是全球生态系统和人类生存支持系统的全面崩溃,这与地理无关。北方人不可能认为它“司空见惯”;这本质上是全人类的生存危机。
活在梦里的猫猫 [楼主] 55分钟前
0 

嘻嘻

爱比较 2小时前
0 
我还是路过吧,证明我浏览过就可以了。
活在梦里的猫猫 [楼主] 55分钟前
0 

hhh,

0 
路过加加加加加加一。
活在梦里的猫猫 [楼主] 25分钟前
0 

0 
一主播放的这个音乐我也有,看末世推文的时候恐怖小说推文的时候他常做背景音乐。 二我觉得极寒末日的存在是有迹可循的,就像楼主所阐明的观点这是有科学依据的。 三我在做一种假设极寒末日的相对面就是即热模式:即热模式温度都升高到六七十度左右那种对大气的破坏对生态系统的毁灭打击人类是很难生存的。 还有,有些小说中所写的地壳板块震动,那几乎人类就要濒临灭亡了。 还有所说的丧尸末日,也违反了物理定律。他们从哪里来摄取能量的?没有能量,他们怎样行动呢?
活在梦里的猫猫 [楼主] 54分钟前
0 

所以说在这些末日中就丧失不合理,不管是高温还是极寒都算是末日

火华 42分钟前
0 
我的翻译是长这样的。 至于“世界末日气温下降二十°c,南方人怕,北方人稀松平常”的说法,则不是这样。北方人习惯于逐渐低温的冬季,并依赖完整的供暖系统、除雪设备和稳定的材料供应链。然而,在末日来临时突然下降20°c是一种没有任何缓冲的极端低温--在此基础上,北方冬季正常的低温将再下降20°c,远远超过了人类的耐受极限。更重要的是,由极端降温引起的基础设施崩溃、供应链中断和社会秩序崩溃是全球性的。北方的抗寒优势会随着供暖的中断和食物的耗尽而完全消失,这不是“耐寒”就能解决的问题。这场灾难的核心是全球生态系统和人类生存支持系统的全面崩溃,与地理无关。北方人不可能认为这是“司空见惯的”;它本质上是全人类的生存危机。
活在梦里的猫猫 [楼主] 36分钟前
0 

垠何 30分钟前
0 
东北一般宁夏是零度和零下一二度。这是平常的天气。下雪以后是零下六七度。那如果全世界全部零下20度,那顶多也就是零下二十八九度也肯定不能冻死人的。顶多就是多加几件衣服的事儿。别问为啥,我知道。因为我老家就是东北那边的。东北漠河
垠何 29分钟前
0 
其实东北没有你们想象的那么冷。只不过就是下雪常发地而已
活在梦里的猫猫 [楼主] 25分钟前
0 

但是这个温度是涉及全球的,并不是所有的生物或者是植物这些都是抗冷的

添加一条新评论

登录后可以发表评论 去登录